The Golden Compass
Starring: Dakota Blue Richards, Nicole Kidman, Ian McKellen, Daniel Craig
Directed by: Chris Weitz
Reviewed by: Conor Flynn

After all the controversy leading up to its release, Phillip Pullman’s masterwork finally hits the big screen after a troubled production. Firstly there was the decision to jettison every religious reference in the script, a judgment which will upset fans of the trilogy. Next and more importantly saw the departure of daunted director Chris Weitz to be replaced by Anand Tucker, who later left due to creative differences, only to be replaced by Weitz again. Finally there was the boycott campaign proposed by the U.S. Catholic League despite the publicised and heavily scrutinised alterations to the script. If you are wondering what all the hullabaloo was about, then read on…
Lyra Belacqua, a child seemingly without parents, lives an idyllic, if almost feral, lifestyle under the watchful eye of the scholars of Jordan College. When her uncle Lord Asriel (Craig) arrives with starling news, she is drawn unknowingly into a political battle of wills. This sees her facing a sinister organisation known as the General Oblation Board, the abduction of children through-out the country, a nomadic tribe of people known as Gyptians, the ferocious armoured bears of the Arctic and witch-clans readying themselves for war. Now if that summary leaves you none the wiser, don’t worry, watching the film will have you stumped as well.
The biggest problem with the film is its pacing and direction which is all over the place. It’s completely incoherent if you haven't read the first book. The film has a more clinical concern to drive multiple plot-points home and misses the ball completely in characterisation. Some characters appear for a few moments then disappear completely without actually establishing who they are or what they are doing. It's also criminally devoid of any of the humour, which makes for extremely stuffy and boring viewing. The comparisons between this film and The Lord of the Rings are unavoidable, but in a completely obtrusive and negative way, for example, every time Lyra looks into the alethiometer, it will instantly remind viewers of Frodo wearing the ring. The CGI itself is very ropey at times, whether it is the various metamorphic daemons or the obviously rendered buildings, nearly everything looks unrealistic.
Is there any saving graces? Well, yes, there is. The acting is generally quite good, particularly the excellent Dakota Blue Richards who plays Lyra. Nicole Kidman’s performance is also good; however her character is seriously neutered. However, the choice to have Ian Mc Kellen voice Iorek Brynison is an extremely bad decision which will meet with derision from fans reminding them of ‘that other trilogy’.
The film can be summed up with the scene in which Lyra crosses a bridge as Iorek Brynison eggs her on. The entire film, much like the path of the bridge, is on thin ice. One can only see poor old Iorek screaming; ‘YOU SHALL NOT PASS!’ Sadly cinema goers and fans alike should pass and by that we mean passing on the film. A hugely disappointing effort…